Rector Search


Actions of service, witness and compassion.


Following the retirement of the Rev. Paula Durren, our Rector for 16 years The Church of the Mediator seeks a new Rector to join us in our ministry and lead us into the future.

The Church of the Mediator commissioned the Search Committee on January 27, 2018.

Search Committee.jpg

Andrew Garrett, Jeannine Totzke, Mary Emrich, Bill Card, Father David Brower, Paul Cromheecke, Susan Collins, Judy Joseph.


Our Prayer for Guidance

In sincere thanksgiving we come to You, Lord, for the many ways You have abundantly blessed us in past years. Now, as we begin a time of discernment and change, guide us in facing these challenges. May we trust You to help us to envision Your perfect plan for us. Empower each of us to play a part in strengthening our commitment to this parish and to our community. You have given each of us talents needed to make our world a better place. May we share these for the good of all. Help us to gratefully show your love in the world. 



Search Committee Update -  July 30, 2019

Thank you for your prayers. We continue meeting and discerning. The documents required by the Diocese are completed and submitted. Canon Spaid will be posting the Rector position in August, and it will remain open for approximately two months, at which time he will close it and begin the review and screening of candidates. Search Committee interviews of the candidates could begin in late October. The Search Committee is now developing a set of questions which will be used with all candidates. Those questions will be keyed around the skills, personality and interests that were identified in the series of conversations held with parishioners after services in May and June. Thank you for your continued support and patience as we work through this very important process.

Search Committee Update -  June 9, 2019

The Search Committee has held and continues to hold conversations after services for input from the parishioners. We are developing two documents required by the Diocese: The Parish Profile, describing who we are and where are we going; and Ministry Portfolio describing our parish. The conversations will also help guide our candidate interview questions. The documents will be presented to Vestry for review/approval in July. Once approved, the Ministry Portfolio will be uploaded to the Diocesan webpage for interested candidates to review. The Parish Profile will be listed on our web site under the Rector Search tab, along with other Search Committee updates for candidates to review.

Search Committee Update -  May 2019

Preparation for a Rector Search include a self-assessment, asking ourselves questions such as who are we, where do we see ourselves going and why do we return to The Mediator. Worshipers were asked to join in small conversations following three services. Members of the Search Committee facilitated each session. The following represent the responses collected. Should you find your response not captured below or you were unable to participate, please give your responses in writing to any member of the Search Committee.

Thank you.

1. How would you describe the Church of the Mediator to your friends?

  • Group 1: Open; warm; welcoming; friendly like family; mostly over the age of 55 but young at heart; mostly retired; seasonal and second homers; accepting of people no matter who they are or where they come from; a “come as you are” church; small church environment; not a neighborhood church but far flung geographically; like God has called people from all over the area to come together; not stuffy at all. There was discussion The Mediator was more right of center than the national church regarding new ministries, advocacy and action on some socially controversial issues - though The Mediator is considered liberal within the region.

  • Group 2: Welcoming; Open to new ideas; Accepting of where/who you are; Non Judgmental; Alright to debate and ask questions; Sense of Humor; Easy to participate in church activities.

  • Group 3: Friendly, welcoming, warm, small, talented, Spirit of God palpably present. Everybody pitches in, place where people love each other, people feel free to bring their gifts no matter what they are, open.

2 and 3. What do you see The Mediator involved with in 5 years? What would you add?

  • Group 1: The next rector should have time and energy for outreach in the community. The building should be used more as a form of outreach such as for concerts. There should be more working within the ecumenical community. More involvement with Neighbor to Neighbor. The Mighty Men of Mediator should be revived or some men’s group should be started; the men need their own group. There should be more involvement with the Harbor Country Food Pantry and the new rector should be more of a presence. There should be more awareness of the Mediator as part of the national Church. We should have an ECW. We should have a 12-month church calendar where it can be seen by everyone where all events for the parish are recorded. We should have an informal Saturday night or Sunday night service; This would be particularly good for working people and in the summer. Suggested that we foster greater engagement with our diocese beyond Vestry to all parishioners, i.e., education and exposure to diocesan initiatives and ministries.

  • Group 2: More outreach if room and volunteers are available; Completing interior work like painting; Ability to encourage new members to get involved without too much push; More diverse in demographics of the church and liturgy; Increased Sunday School and Youth Programs, the ability to bring in new participants; Acquire evangelism skills;

  • Group 3: More outreach, more inviting to everyone, more young people, more children, more Christian education, more updated and streamlined liturgy, more involvement from people from this geographical area, more relieving human suffering, more involvement in area schools and nursing homes as specific individuals or groups representing The Mediator, more involvement with the LGBTQ community. If you could add something, what would it be? parish hall, organist, more lay servers

4. What keeps you coming back to The Mediator?

  • Group 1: The people. My faith. The liturgy. The people are very engaged, everybody is in the boat rowing together. It is a pretty church, it looks well cared for, not too old, not too high, charming, warm, simple. There is no obstacle to worship in the church (architecturally). It is possible to participate on all levels. There is no rigid structure so you don’t have to “break in” if you are new. We are lucky to be small because large churches that have lost numbers are rattling around in their large buildings and feeling terrible. There was some discussion that reflected anxiety about who we would be able to call. And some concern expressed that we might have trouble discerning who the applicant really is and what his ministry would really be like for the parish. That the applicant might say one thing and do another, That the applicant might use us as a stepping stone.

  • Group 2: The community; Friends, feels like family, Relationships are always healthy, The people and philosophy of the church, Comfortable liturgy. The overall gist of the church is that we are a loving and open church. We discussed the need to increase our congregation with younger people. When someone started talking about the type of priest we needed, I politely interrupted and explained to everyone that we are not ready to get that information at this time and we needed to figure out who we are and what we need as a church first. Once that was said, everyone understood and we moved quickly through the questions. Janada made a comment that more outreach will have to wait until we have more involvement with the congregation. We are doing a lot of outreach and it is hard to fill the volunteer slots at times. It was noted that many unfinished interior building projects for the church need to be completed. Marilee brought up a good point, our church does not use media sources anymore to advertise our church and services. We need to market the church better to bring in more interest. There are free services and it might be worth paying for a good placement of an ad if the church can afford to budget.

  • Group 3: What keeps you coming back to The Mediator? Feeling fulfilled, encouragement from others, sense of being cared for by others, a place to pray, the people, the feeling of the place, the church becomes your family.. The greatest emphasis was on the fact that the congregation is loving and caring. The most discussion was about outreach to the community. People got excited about the idea to form groups that would volunteer as a Mediator entity in various locations like schools and nursing homes. They also talked about activities like drama classes or art classes as a means of attracting people to the church.


Search Committee Update - 4/25/2019

Members: Andrew Garrett, Sue Collins, Judy Joseph, Mary Emrich, Paul Cromheecke, Jeannine Totzke and Bill Card. 

The Committee convened for two months by teleconferencing while the Chair was out of town but now all are meeting face to face.  During that time ground work was laid for the documents we must prepare.  That preparation began with meeting one on one with worshipers after church – thank you!  Briefly, those discussions confirmed what we all suspected: we are a welcoming, inclusive church, talented and non-judgmental.  The future, if we could fashion it, would have more community groups utilizing our facility, continued outreach proportionate to our resources and labor, and a greater media profile in the Harbor Country.  Folks said they come back for the liturgy, community and encouragement.

We are drafting the Ministry Profile of who we are at Mediator.  This document will become part of the electronic data base at the Diocese which will be viewed by those seeking a position within the Diocese.

We are drafting a second document, Parish Profile, which describes us in greater detail which includes our history, our ministries, our community and the services extended to our community – in narrative form and photographs.  This rich description is the document on which a prospective applicant frequently bases their decision to look further.

We are preparing a Rector Profile Survey for each parishioner to complete, helping us to develop the profile with the broadest representation of how we wish to be led.  These comments will also help shape the questions for our candidate interviews.

We anticipate rolling out each of the documents in May.  The acceptance of these documents is required by the Diocese and once accepted the active search process begins.

We encourage you to speak with any committee member throughout this process.

Thank you for your prayers.